
Who Goes There?
I was supposed to write about a Clare Winger Harris story months ago, in fact her debut, “A Runaway World.” The problem was that not only did I not like the story, I wasn’t even sure what to write about it. Mind you that this was not my first run-in with Harris, having also read “The Miracle of the Lily,” which is considerably better. Harris has a curious life story behind her, so it’s a shame that to this day much of her life remains a mystery to us. She was born in 1891 in Freeport, Illinois. Her father was himself a published author, while her maternal grandfather was the wealthiest man in Freeport. She eventually married Frank Clyde Harris, who was an architect, engineer, and associate professor. So, Harris grew up with some educated and financially well-off people, which was not a given at the tail end of the 19th century. She also seemed to have caught the writing bug from her old man, since by the time she made her SF debut in 1926 she had already written a novel (her only novel, in fact), titled Persephone of Eleusis: A Romance of Ancient Greece, a work of historical fiction. For reasons we’re not sure about, Harris then pivoted to writing SF.
As far as the historians has so far been able to tell, Harris was the first woman to have her work published in the SF magazines under her own name and without her first name initialed to hide her gender. In his introductory blurb for “The Fate of the Poseidonia,” Hugo Gernsback writes that “as a rule, women do not make good scientifiction writers,” (uh oh) “because their education and general tendencies on scientific matters are usually limited.” Not sure what he means by “general tendencies,” but as far as education goes he was unfortunately correct for the time. After all, women in the US were only granted the right to vote in 1920, just seven years earliear, and options for higher education were still pretty limited. Harris was a member of that very first generation of educated women (who would’ve been white and coming from at least middle-class backgrounds) to write for the genre magazines. “The Fate of Poseidonia” is just as good and probably better than a lot of the SF written by men at the time, although I’m still not sure if I would call it a “good” story.
Placing Coordinates
First published in the June 1927 issue of Amazing Stories. It was reprinted only once in Harris’s lifetime, in the collection Away from the Here and Now, and it would stay that way for a few more decades. Since the turn of the millennium, however, it has gotten a new lease on life, being reprinted several times since 2000, in The Prentice Hall Anthology of Science Fiction and Fantasy (ed. Garyn G. Roberts), Daughters of Earth: Feminist Science Fiction in the Twentieth Century (ed. Justine Larbalestier), The Best of Amazing Stories: The 1927 Anthology (ed. Steve Davidson and Jean Marie Stein), The Big Book of Science Fiction (ed. Ann and Jeff VanderMeer), and the Harris collection The Artificial Man and Other Stories.
Enhancing Image
When I wrote my review forecast earlier this month I said “The Fate of the Poseidonia” featured a heroine, which turned out to be incorrect. Either the folks at the SF Encyclopedia stretched things beyond the breaking point, or had confused it with a different Harris story. Our “hero” is very much a man, although George Gregory is not a hero in any meaningful sense. At the outset of the story he’s a young man with a girlfriend, named Margaret, but aside from her and Professor Stearns he doesn’t have any real friends, living in a hotel room and ignoring his neighbors. He also finds his relationship with Margaret has become increasingly strained, or rather distant, which is a sign that a breakup is imminent. What ultimately happens is worse than “just” a breakup, though. Gregory discovers a rival for Margaret’s affection, in the form of Martell, a strange man of about the same age but with a “swarthy, coppery hue” to his skin, “not unlike that of an American Indian.” So, he’s red, and for an amazing reason. Martell is not, as Gregory, Native American, but… let’s be honest and say he is clearly a Martian. The two even meet at a lecture Professors Stearns is giving about canals and potential life on Mars, said lecture proving very relevant.
The twist that Martell is a Martian on Earth is so obvious (at least to a modern reader) that even someone suffering from tunnel vision will catch it early. That Gregory quickly becomes convinced something is off about Martell proves to be a correct hunch, but the lengths Gregory goes to try to get dirt on his romantic rival strain the reader’s sympathy for him. Not only is he an anti-hero, if anything, but he also gets cucked, with Margaret deciding to dump him and go out with Martell instead. To make matters worse, the world’s sea levels have gone down seemingly overnight, leaving unnumerable fish dying on shrunken shores and a fraction’s of the world’s water having mysteriously vanished. The Pegasus, a “transatlantic passenger-plane,” has also gone missing, presumably along with the ocean water. No one knows how this happened, but Gregory has a feeling Martell has something to do with it. (I mean, he’s right.) You may be thinking, where’s the Poseidonia that the story’s title alludes to? We’ll get to that later. Truth be told, the title is sort of a misnomer, since for most of the story the mystery is centered on the fate of the Pegasus. I may have given Martell being a Martian early, but there are plot points that are less obvious.
(By the way, this might just an error typically found in old magazines, and I don’t have any other version of this story on hand, but the chronology of events is confusing. We’re told that the inciting incident happened in the winter of 1894-95, when Gregory and Margaret would be somewhere in their twenties. But the lowering of the ocean levels and the disappearance of the Pegasis are said to happen in 1945, fifty years later. But fifty years have certainly not passed since the story’s beginning. Hell, not even a full year it seems like. Most likely the year we’re given at the beginning is supposed to be 1944-5, but I can’t be sure right now.)
As you can tell from the premise, speculation about life on Mars was a lot more optimistic in 1927 than just a few decades later. First there was speculation about life on Earth’s moon, and then on Mars. There was the frequen that somewhere in our solar system, preferably closer rather than farther away from Earth, there might be intelligent life that can become friends with mankind. We hoped we might not be alone in the known universe. Well, 99 years later and we’re still alone. As for Martell, this might be the first time Martians are written as having skin tone akin to the indigenous peoples of North America. As far as classic alien skin tones go there’s basically little green men and the grays, meanwhile the Martians of H. G. Wells’s The War of the Worlds stay hidden inside their giant metal tripods. But Martians being red-skinned or thereabouts would become the norm for depicting humanoid Martians until at least the ’60s. Of course, by the ’60s we knew there was no such intelligent life on Mars. Harris was forward-thinking in this regard. She also anticipated the proliferation of commercial air flight with a reasonable time frame, although it would take a decade or two longer in real life for airplanes to become commercially the norm than in-story. The 1945 of the story is obviously different from the 1945 we really got, but it’s by no means far-fetched.
Well, except for the Martian business.
Another thing Harris anticipates is a TV set small enough to fit in the comfort of one’s own home. A big plot point is Gregory spying on Martell’s abode and sneaking in when the Martian is out. Aside from this being illegal at the very least, Gregory does discover some decidedly not-human tech, namely a TV-radio combo he dubs the “devil-machine.” Evidently this is how Martell is able to communicate with other Martians. More strangely, Gregory is able to look into far-off places with this machine, convincing him there is some coordinated plot and that Martell and his men are indeed not of Earth. Nah, really? Made even more obvious when Gregory sees one of these Martians with his arms bared, and for some reason they have little sets of feathers. Why would a humanoid need feathers? Never gets explained. Made more inexplicable because aside from the skin tone and texture, and the feathers, these aliens totally pass for human. We unfortunately do not get truly alien aliens in this story.
There Be Spoilers Here
The one thing that really surprised me about “The Fate of the Poseidonia” is that it has a downer ending. The bad guys win. Well, it might be unfair to call the Martians bad, since they have a legitimate reason for taking some of Earth’s water: Mars does have canals, but unfortunately life on the red planet threatens to be snuffed out because of a water crisis. There were some casualties in taking the two planes, but you can’t make an omelet without cracking a few eggs. The ending is absolutely a downer for Gregory, though. He’s been locked up in a mental institution, with no one except Professor Stearns believing him. Margaret has gone off to Mars with Martell, and was in fact the sole survivor of the Poseidonia. She expresses her regret in trusting Martell, in the brief time she has to talk with Gregory, but the signal’s cut and it’s assumed the two will never see each other again. This story does not have a heroine, as the SF Encyclopedia claims, but it does have maybe the most impotent male “hero” of any Gernsback-era SF story. Maybe a male writer would’ve given Gregory some kind of out, but Harris gives her shitty protagonist the worst outcome. This is an admirable and morbid curveball, for a story that’s otherwise predictable.
A Step Farther Out
Did I like “The Fate of the Poseidonia”? Not really. Harris’s style is pretty creaky, and the small type for the magazine version made the physical act of reading rather hard on the eyes. 99 years of science fiction have also rendered the plot, about Martians in disguise plotting to steal resources from Earth, feel all too familiar—for the most part. I will say, Harris making her male lead a petty and insecure cuckold who ultimately isn’t rewarded at all for his actions seems like a deliberate choice. It’s a deeply unflattering depiction of fragile masculinity that would speak to a modern reader far more than the writing on a technical level. With that in mind, it has aged relatively well for a Gernsback-era story.
See you next time.








