
The Story So Far
Some 3,000 years in the future, mankind has splintered into two major groups, the Earthmen and the Spacers. The Spacers are the descendants of humans who left Earth to colonize nearby planets centuries ago, and there’s grown a mutual resentment between the easy-living Spacers and those on Earth who live in “caves.” Countries have long since given way to capital-C Cities, mostly autonomous city-states that are both massive in dimension and separated by fields of wilderness and agriculture. To cope with Earth’s population problem (Asimov really thought eight billion people would push Earth’s resources to the breaking point), the people are kept in these Cities and subjected to a kind of demerit system, in which those who become “declassified” are restricted to the most rudimentary food and shelter. Of course, being guaranteed food and shelter in the first place (the terminology surrounding the system of government is kept vague here, but given the lack of currency it can be considered a form of state socialism) is still better than nothing. Elijah Baley remembers, however, those dark days in his youth after his once-respected father got declassified and the family had to subsist on vat-grown food and a lack of privacy. Baley is also, as is common among Earthmen, not a fan of robots.
Baley is a police detective, rank C-5, and his latest case is his most unusual yet: the death of a Spacer called Dr. Sarton. Sarton was one of a small number of Spacers stationed in Spacetown, an outpost on the outskirts of New York (the City New York, which we’re told is different from the historical New York we’re all familiar with), and the Spacers want a hand in the ensuing investigation. For better or worse, Baley is not to work alone, but is to have a partner, R. Daneel Olivaw, who is in fact a robot, but who appears to be just as human as any normal man. According to Commissioner Julius Enderby, the idea here is that Baley is to solve the case before R. Daneel does, for the sake of PR, despite Daneel being by every metric a better detective than Baley—indeed embodying the kind of plainclothesman Baley wishes he was. Baley has a promotion to think about, but also the wellbeing of his wife and son. This is an odd case, and of course the Spacers are not very helpful. Dr. Sarton was in Spacetown when he was killed, and in order to get from the outside to in, there are realistically only two options, if you’re the kind of person to kill a defenseless scientist: either you cross the wilderness under cover of night, which psychologically is night impossible for an Earthman, or (equally unlikely) a robot is responsible for the killing. Of course, to paraphrase Sherlock Holmes, once you’ve removed the impossible, the unlikely becomes the only option.
Asimov pulls a “both sides have issues” maneuver with the Earthmen and Spacers, which normally would irk me, but the bits of worldbuilding he crams into what nowadays would be considered a short novel are admirable. The Spacers, living in low-density colonies in the so-called Outer Worlds, have achieved what seems like paradise, except the cost is steep. For one, the Spacers have a eugenics program in which infants diagnosed with defects are euthanized, the wheat scythed from the chaff. These people are also major-league germaphobes, and with good reason, as even Earth’s common cold would render a Spacer bedridden, if not kill him. They’ve built up no immunity to foreign diseases. The irony is that by spending centuries cultivating a semi-utopia free of disease and filth, the Spacers have rendered themselves rather weak; and unlike the Earthmen, they have the problem of there being too few people in the colonies. Baley is disturbed by all this, understandably, but there’s also the problem of the Medievalists on Earth and what seems to be a conspiracy around Dr. Sarton’s murder. A near-riot at a store early in the novel may have been staged, and it looks like even Jessie, Baley’s wife, might be in on it.
Enhancing Image
It’s rewarding to reread books you consider your favorites periodically; could be every five years, maybe even every two years, or in the case of The Caves of Steel, it’s been about a decade. My reading comprehension skills when I was a teen were not on the level of what they are now, but also the passage of time naturally fogs one’s vision. There are things about this novel I remember more vividly than were actually evident in the text, and conversely there are a few things that are objectively important which had somehow slipped utterly from my memory. For one, I had completely forgotten about the Spacers’ own agenda regarding the murder mystery and how this factors into Baley trying to solve the damn thing more or less on his own. See, a reason for why Sarton’s death plays second fiddle in the narrator, despite being technically the sun around which the plot revolves, is that the Spacers themselves are not terribly concerned with solving the case, but instead they have a secret ulterior motive involving Baley and the Medievalists. Now, we haven’t been able to interact with Spacers much throughout the novel, in large part thanks to the setting, but like Baley the reader is nudged into distrusting them, on account of their smarminess and what we learn about the Outer Worlds, if nothing else. It’s a neat little subversion, then, that the Spacers’ secret agenda ends up being sympathetic—hell, not only that but mutually beneficial for both Spacers and Earthmen. This idea of Asimov’s of a shadowy group having secretly sympathetic motives is not unique to this novel, as off the top of my head I can also think of “The Dead Past,” which is a contender for Asimov’s single finest short story.
Now, in order for Baley to solve the mystery of Sarton’s killing, several things have to go right, and also Baley has to have a brain-blast moment at literally the eleventh hour, before he’s officially taken off the case. The Caves of Steel is a detective novel of the classic sort, albeit in an SFnal setting, and like classic detective novels the final stretch sees the hero catching the culprit and then explaining just how the culprit could’ve committed the crime. Well, it doesn’t follow exactly this formula, since Baley doesn’t have strong enough evidence to throw Enderby behind bars—at least not without a confession. Now, if you’ve read this book before or by some slim chance have been following along with me, it’s pretty obvious Enderby is the one who did it, despite being subjected to a test by Daneel early in the novel and cleared. By the endgame, Enderby is shown to be the only one who could’ve possibly had the opportunity to kill Sarton, but the question still remained as to the means and motive. When I first read The Caves of Steel as a dumb teen, I was underwhelmed that one of the very first characters we meet, indeed the first person who could be considered a suspect, turned out to be the killer after all; that we’re told right away about Enderby’s Medievalist tendencies and how this might tie into the larger conspiracy doesn’t help either. Of course, another subversion Asimov delivers is that Enderby didn’t mean to kill Sarton: the killing was a case of mistaken identity. See, Sarton had made the mistake of modeling Daneel after himself, so that the two appear practically identical. The result is that Enderby had killed Sarton when he had meant to kill Daneel, but also this mistake explains Enderby’s aversion to looking at Daneel directly throughout the novel, as well as why Enderby would sort of throw Baley under the bus.
The final question, and maybe the most fun part of all this, is then the how. Just how did Enderby do it? Because Sarton had been shot with a blaster (they call guns “blasters” in this novel like it’s Star Wars, it’s kinda funny), and not only was there no blaster at the scene of the crime but Enderby would’ve had to hand over his blaster before entering Spacetown; and again, Enderby did not trek through the outdoors to get to Sarton (he simply doesn’t have the psychology for it), so that’s ruled out. Ah, but a robot could trek through the outdoors without issue. A robot could also carry a gun, provided said robot doesn’t use it or aim it at a human being, as the three laws dictate. Similarly to the stories making up I, Robot, however, The Caves of Steel shows how the three laws can be exploited, and how, in this case, a robot can be made unwittingly an accomplice to murder. R. Sammy, the robot secretary at the police station, is found terminated late in the novel, and it’s obviously as to who could’ve done such a thing and why. Sammy had brought and then received Enderby’s blaster, apparently without knowing the purpose, only for Enderby to kill him later once the commissioner realized the robot could be used as evidence against him. All this evidence is rathertr circumstantial, but not enough for a conviction, hence Baley backing Enderby into a corner and getting a confession from him—not that Enderby ends up going to jail anyway. Even so, it’s satisfying for Baley’s character development since it shows him really earning his stripes as a detective, not to mention that promotion he was promised.
A Step Farther Out
The Caves of Steel might be the best serial I’ve reviewed in the four years I’ve been running this site, which is kinda sad because it’s a novel I had read before. 1953 was such a banger year for SF that despite being worthy of a win, The Caves of Steel ended up only fourth on the final ballot for the Retro Hugo for Best Novel. If you’re wary of Asimov’s habits as a writer then this probably won’t change your mind, but at the same time it shows Asimov at the height of his powers, arguably an even higher peak than Foundation. It’s not as outwardly ambitious as Foundation, but The Caves of Steel is quietly home to some of Asimov’s most impressive worldbuilding. My having read a good deal of classic crime fiction in the years I’d last read this novel also added to my appreciation, I must admit, and also I have a soft spot for crime fiction of the hardboiled variety. I’ll eventually get around to tackling The Naked Sun, which I have a far less vivid memory of, probably around this same time next year. Should be good.
See you next time.